Hmm... Here's the article. It appears in the National Review which is respectable and the guy is apparently writing a book on the subject (the article isn't quite as confrontational as the title). Since this is flexible blog land and I've written quite a lot on the subject, I'd like to get a response from anyone who clicks through to read it (this means you Trevor). I'll post it here if you like, or I'll check your blog.
Does it seem reasonable?