Monday, August 04, 2008

Last post!

Two readers (about half my readers in other words) asked if I was giving up blogging because of the way I started the post below. I was talking about the last post in my recent discussion with Trevor. My post was terribly worded and thanks for your concern, but next time, try to sound a little more alarmed! I've written over 650 posts people! Giving up so suddenly would be a Big Deal (for me).

So anyway, I had a first draft of this post but it got overlong. It actually wounds my soul a little to delete so much, but hopefully it'll be good for your soul.

  1. I look forward to Trevor making an equally big deal of this when discussing all other topics.
  2. This may come across as nitpicking, but I've never seen this asserted. Seriously. The logical conclusion is basically not to eat any meat that's commercially available.
  3. I think it's important to note that many vegetarians don't believe this.


     

    But I also think it's important to note that this is not what our discussion was about and I explicitly said as much. It's complicated and contested philosophically, but Trevor's failure to understand how anyone could think this is partly just because he hasn't read the relevant stuff. What makes it wrong to painlessly kill a human?

I think Trevor's most baffling bit is where he says, "but then you are not a vegetarian." Apparently we've been talking all this time without even having a common understanding of what it means to be a vegetarian! Does Trevor think I'm a vegetarian? I've kinda been assuming that he thinks I am one. But judging by this post I don't even come close, because he knows I eat some types of seafood. This is especially frustrating because it was people's impatience with any explanation of why I sometimes eat fish that led me to adopt the overly simple label of Vegetarian even though this means I occasionally get people gleefully pointing out that fish are animals. I doubt my experience is that unusual but suddenly a vegetarian is someone who will never eat meat?

Trevor poses overly strict demands on vegetarians; I doubt there are many out there who would starve rather than eat chicken. It should be assumed that we'll eat meat under certain circumstances. There are many types of vegetarian and I think a reasonable definition of one is someone who simply doesn't eat meat as a general rule.

Another factual issue is tripping us up again. How much meat is out there that we can be sure is cruelty free? I'd suggest very little, which is enough to make vegetarianism sensible. A dinner guest who demands cruelty free documentation is more annoying than a vegetarian. If you get used to going without meat you can also start to get a little grossed out by the idea of eating it. I've mentioned that in practice, even those who endorse the whole cruelty free thing tolerate little inconvenience to act on this conviction (I used my example of diary), it's best to get into the habit.

And of course we've simply ignored the arguments claiming that even painless killing is unethical, which, even if without engaging with them we assign a mysteriously low % of being sound, should still give us pause.

3 comments:

Stacy said...

Ok, I'm just gonna go out on a limb here, but I'm starting to believe more and more why some people have such a hard time grasping what it means to be a vegetarian and why....sometimes when I tell people I'm a vegetarian they DEMAND an explanation and it's usually not good enough (I really would never demand to know why people are of a certain religion or why people eat meat for that matter but that's a different story). Then an argument usually follows whereby I am the target of someone who is offended by the idea of not eating meat, as if our meat eating ancestors would be ashamed at my behavior. They then assume that maybe I'm just trying to be overly moral or trendy. I can guarantee you I'm not. And I'm probably not a very good vegetarian for that matter, just like I'm not a very good Christian...I never try to convert people. I really should care more but the truth is, I DON'T. I just don't want to participate in eating meat because I think it's cruel, unnecessary and a little gross. Those are my personal reasons. But back to my point...

Why must I have to feel somehow that what I'm doing(or not doing) is offensive to people when all I'm doing is taking something that I think is right and making it a part of my life? I also don't get why intelligent people can't understand why I don't eat meat. You don't have to agree with it, but please admit you UNDERSTAND. That doesn't make you somehow morally obligated to change your eating habits....and I doubt that most vegetarians would expect you to....that is all.....

Anonymous said...

kramixer crack
submitwolf crack
fl studio demo v5.0.1 crack
pppshar pro crack
mytheatre 3.20.02 crack
war craft iii crack
email scheduler crack
windows registry repair se 2.0 keygen
cs2 keygen photo shop
edgecam crack




microsoft onenote serial crack
stylebuilder keygen 2.0 beta
home designer pro 6 crack
blaze dvd crack
windows xp activation code keygen
windows xp home edition keygen
jedi knight 2 jedi outcast no cd crack
morpheus ultra 4.7.0 keygen
monopoly pocket pc crack
finale 2005 demo crack
absynth 2 crack
eovideo 1.36 crack
igetter crack
worms 4 mayhem crack
magic ball 2 crack yahoo
hot rod american drag crack
viz4 crack
acid 5 pro keygen
autocad 2004 lt keygen
netchat 2.5 crack

Anonymous said...

mobile net switch 3.1 keygen
crack for nero 6 ultra edition 6.6.0.5
wingate 5.0.1 crack
pal spyware remover crack
gamebox solitaire ii crack




glyfx warez
msdict crack
windows media center edition crack
battle for middle earth keygen download
vue desprit 4 crack
sony sound forge keygen
3ds studio max 7 crack
crack for norton antivirus 2005 trial
vcdeasy 2.1.1 crack serial
nero serial crack 6.6.0.6
boris continuum crack
paint shop pro 9 crack download
crack spread definition
converter keygen smartmovie
ayanova crack
zone alarm password crack
outpost firewall pro 2.5 keygen
movie collector 4.4 crack keygen
camedia master pro crack
avi to vcd svcd dvd converter 3.02 crack